My ex-boyfriend was an idol.


Chapter 06: If Only You Would Come Back

When Namthap returned from Karan's flat, Thir gave him such a long lecture that he was sweating by the time he finally escaped. He stood leaning against his balcony and exhaled a thin stream of grey smoke. The smell of cigarettes drifted through the air as his eyes wandered towards the sky. The moon shone beautifully against the darkness, but tonight it hung alone, without the stars that usually surrounded it.

 

Such a beautiful sight, yet so lonely. Just like him. No matter how brightly the moon shone, without its stars to keep it company, it seemed lonely and joyless.

 

He didn't know when looking at the moon had stopped making him happy. Thinking about it, though, it must have been when P'Ran was no longer beside him. Gazing at that beautiful moon for too long always drew his thoughts back to the past.

 

To their happy past... Two young men walked side by side along the pavement at night. The streetlights and moonlight cast a beautiful glow over them.

 

"How was practice today, Namthap? Are you very tired?" Karan asked gently as he walked home with his boyfriend.

 

"I'm sooooo tired today!"

 

Remembering his gruelling rehearsals, nineteen-year-old Namthap complained softly and rubbed his head against Karan's slender arm, seeking affection. How could he not be tired? He'd been rehearsing since school finished, and it was already past eleven at night.

 

"Ha ha! You poor boy."

 

Karan laughed and ruffled his boyfriend's thick hair. Namthap pouted slightly, making Karan smile even more fondly. That smile bewitched Namthap. He stood transfixed, as though caught in a dream.

 

It was radiant, like the moon glowing in the night sky. Their steps came to a halt because Namthap simply stood looking at him. Karan lifted his brows in confusion.

 

"What's wrong? Why have you stopped?"

 

"P'..."

 

"Hmm?"

 

"You're so beautiful, P'. Do you know that?" Namthap asked sweetly.

 

Karan had no idea what to do with himself. His pale ears and cheeks turned bright red. However hard he tried to hide it, the blush was proof enough of how embarrassed he felt. He wanted the ground to swallow him.

 

"W-what are you talking about? Don't be ridiculous. How could I be beautiful?"

 

"You are! You're so beautiful, P'. The most beautiful person in the whole world."

 

The more flustered Karan became, the more Namthap wanted to tease him, but every word he said was true. The most beautiful thing in the world was P'Ran's smile. That radiant smile, shining with love and overflowing happiness, was too beautiful to look away from.

 

If he could, Namthap would tell everyone on earth who possessed the most beautiful smile in the world. It was so dazzling he wanted everyone to see it. He didn't want to keep such a precious smile all to himself.

 

"I'm not talking to you any more!"

 

Karan puffed out his cheeks indignantly and tried to walk away from the teasing, though he still reached back to pull Namthap along. Namthap laughed softly at his expression and affectionately tapped the tip of his upturned nose.

 

"Ha ha! You're blushing!"

 

"Y-you awful boy!"

 

The teasing made Karan even more sulky. Namthap found him impossibly endearing. How could someone become even cuter the more embarrassed he was? How many more times could Namthap fall in love with him?

 

"P', the moon is beautiful tonight," Namthap said, tipping his head back.

 

Karan looked up too.

 

"It really is beautiful."

 

His warm eyes remained fixed on the moon, paying no attention to the young man beside him. Namthap looked away from the bright moon and turned towards his lover with adoration.

 

"Mm. Really beautiful."

 

But he wasn't talking about the moon. To Namthap, nothing was more beautiful than the person standing next to him. His gaze was filled with deep love and devotion as he studied Karan's lovely face.

 

"..."

 

"Did you know we can send wishes to other people through the moon? They say wishes made to the moon come true. Since we all look at the same moon, our wishes can reach one another."

 

"Is that really a thing? Who would do that? I'm not a child, you know."

 

"You don't have to be a child to make a wish. There's no harm in trying it once."

 

"Sigh. All right, then."

 

At his boyfriend's insistence, Karan gave in. He clasped his hands before his chest and closed his eyes to make a wish. If wishes really can reach another person, please let Namthap and the boys succeed in everything they've dreamed of.

 

Please don't let anything hurt my boys. While Karan made his wish, Namthap clasped his own hands and prayed too. Please let P'Ran be happy.

 

Let us stay together forever. I... I want to be with him so much.

 

So please, Moon, don't let anything tear us apart. They slowly opened their eyes at almost the same moment. Seeing that Namthap had prayed as well, Karan turned to ask curiously:

 

"What did you wish for?"

 

"I wished that the two of us could stay together forever."

 

"You didn't need to wish for that. I'm not going to leave you, whatever happens."

 

Karan frowned, not understanding why he'd wished for such a thing. The little rascal made it sound as though they weren't going to stay together.

 

"I wanted to wish for it. I want the moon to be our witness."

 

"Have you forgotten you're not supposed to tell anyone what you've wished for?"

 

"Then why didn't you tell me that first?!"

 

Namthap puffed out his cheeks, his handsome face growing sulky. Karan burst out laughing.

 

"Ha ha! You silly boy!"

 

He reached up and tousled Namthap's hair until it stuck out everywhere.

 

"Hmph. You're teasing me again, P'."

 

"Ha ha! All right, I'll stop. Let's go home. You've had a tiring rehearsal, so we should get back and rest."

 

"Okay. Let's go home."

 

"Mm. Let's go to our home."

 

They clasped each other's hands tightly against the cold wind. It was such an ordinary moment, yet filled with so much warmth. Back then, life had been simple and happy.

 

They could live with the person they loved without hiding or keeping secrets. They'd been so happy... Namthap lowered his gaze to the cigarette in his hand.

 

He wasn't normally a smoker. He'd quit because P'Ran told him smoking was bad for him, and because P'Ran was sensitive to cigarette smoke. Remembering that, Namthap immediately stubbed it out.

 

He stared at the moon in the night sky, slowly clasped his hands and closed his eyes in prayer. I pray to the moon: please let P'Ran be happy. Let us be together again.

 

Let us hold hands and overcome the obstacles standing in our way. As long as I can have P'Ran beside me, I'll endure much pain however I must. I'll endure all of it.

 

Please help us. Please let our love find happiness. If we're still looking at the same moon, I hope my wish reaches you, P'Ran.

 

Karan's morning should have been peaceful. He had the entire day free, but a close university senior ruined his chance to relax.

 

"Yes, P'Mek?" he answered sleepily, his eyes still shut.

 

[Ran, could you do me a favour?] The anxious voice made Karan curious.

 

"Is something wrong?"

 

[I've got a photography appointment with a client, but my assistant's suddenly fallen ill and had to go to the hospital. Ran, please come and help me. I'm begging you.]

 

"Of course. What time?"

 

[Ten o'clock sharp, at Studio A.]

 

"All right. I'll see you there."

 

Karan readily agreed. He was free all day anyway, and P'Mek had helped him a great deal when they were studying. He couldn't stand by and do nothing when someone so close to him needed help. After ending the call, he got up, showered and dressed.

 

Before long, he was neatly dressed, with his bag packed. He checked that everything was in order and went down to his car. The drive from his condominium to the photography studio was short.

 

On arrival, he got out with his bag and a coffee he'd bought on the way. He walked towards their meeting place, then looked around in surprise. The studio staff were all unusually excited, as though an important celebrity were about to arrive.

 

"Oh, Ran! You're here!"

 

Karan turned towards the familiar voice. Mekha, or P'Mek, his senior from university, was walking over, plainly delighted to see him.

 

"Hello, P'Mek. Who are we photographing today? Everyone seems so excited."

 

"Oh... I completely forgot to tell you. Today's models are idols."

 

"Idols?"

 

"Yes, male idols. Apparently they're very famous, although I don't know much about that sort of thing."

 

Male idols. Very famous? Please don't let this be what he was thinking...

 

"Do you happen to know the group's name?"

 

"The X. Apparently they're huge. My younger sister's a fan, so I've heard a little about them. Do you know them?"

 

Karan went completely still. Know them? Far more than that. This was going to be exhausting.

 

"There they are now," Mekha announced, drawing Karan's attention to the four famous young bandmates walking into the studio with their manager.

 

Karan tried to make himself as inconspicuous as possible when the five approached. It was no use. Phimraphat had already noticed him.

 

Phim's eyes widened. He clapped a hand over his mouth and excitedly told his bandmates. A moment later, all five were staring straight at Karan.

 

"P'Ran!" "P'!" "P'Ran!" "P'!"

 

Four enormous young men rushed over to surround him from every direction. The sight was almost comical. Oh, no. Was he going to survive today's job?

 

"P'! It's been ages! Do you know how much I've missed you?"

 

Jay rested his face against Karan's slender shoulder and nuzzled him affectionately. Phim promptly copied him. They both leaned and rubbed against him until Namthap's brow twitched ominously.

 

Keen noticed the murderous atmosphere emanating from their tall friend and discreetly prodded the two troublemakers, but they clung on stubbornly. Having done all he could, Keen gave up. Every man for himself.

 

If they wanted to get hurt, that was their problem. He wouldn't be the one suffering. Finally, Thir couldn't bear watching his charges fawn over Karan so openly.

 

He marched over and pulled the two away, giving all four a stern look. Phim and Jay promptly fell silent.

 

"Go and get changed. The stylists are waiting," Thir ordered.

 

The four slunk off towards the changing room with their heads lowered. Only Karan and Thir remained. Mekha had already gone to supervise the crew and make his final checks before the shoot.

 

"How have you been? It's been a long time. We didn't even get to talk properly last time," Thir said in a friendly tone.

 

There was nothing awkward or tense between them, only an old familiarity that stirred memories.

 

"It has been a long time. I've been well. How about you?"

 

"Not bad. Just rather busy with work."

 

"Being a band's manager must be hard work."

 

"Mm. Something like that."

 

"It's certainly exhausting without you helping out."

 

The models were soon brought onto the prepared set and briefed on the concept for the day's photographs. Once everyone was in position, the shoot began. Click, click, click.

 

"Very good!"

 

The camera shutters clicked constantly. All four were extremely professional, knowing their best angles and how to pose. Karan and Thir looked between the models and the photographs with satisfaction. Click, click, click.

 

"Excellent! Okay, let's take a break and change the set!"

 

Once Mekha, the shoot director, was satisfied with the images, he called for the next set. The crew rushed over to help the models change clothes and prepare their hair and make-up. The photographs were intended for The X's forthcoming third-anniversary album, so the concept was warm and family-oriented.

 

While the four idols changed, Karan, Thir and Mekha sat together reviewing the first set of photographs. All three were pleased.

 

"These look really good," Karan said.

 

"They really are beautiful," Mekha agreed.

 

"You're both very talented," Thir told them. "The results are excellent. The fans will love these pictures."

 

"Thank you. The boys are brilliant too. They convey the emotions perfectly, don't they, Ran?"

 

"Yes. Each of them has a very different style, yet they fit together wonderfully."

 

Karan spoke with genuine admiration. The four young men each had their own image and aura, but together they were remarkably harmonious. Their expressions conveyed the warmth of friendship and family.

 

"Thank you on their behalf," Thir replied.

 

The three discussed the pictures enthusiastically until the next set was ready and the models returned in fresh outfits. The crew immediately resumed shooting. Every set went smoothly, although something kept bothering Karan throughout: the reproachful look in Namthap's eyes. He knew the boy was still upset that he'd sent him away.

 

Karan could only sigh when he saw that his normally bright, smiling puppy seemed so dejected today. Click, click, click. The photography continued from midday until five in the afternoon.

 

Everyone was delighted when the session finally ended successfully. The four idols went off to change while Mekha continued checking the images. Once again, only Karan and Thir were left together.

 

"Hey, can I ask you something?"

 

"Of course."

 

"What made you agree to appear on that programme?"

 

"The programme contacted me. It looked interesting, so I agreed. I had no idea the other guest would be Namthap."

 

"That boy is impossibly stubborn. No matter how much I tell him not to do something, he never listens," Thir muttered, irritated by his charge's obstinacy.

 

"Tell him not to?" Karan asked in confusion.

 

"The programme contacted us too. I told him he couldn't go, but he wouldn't listen."

 

"So Namthap knew about it beforehand?"

 

"Yes. Namthap was the one who submitted your name to the programme. Now I'm worried about what might happen when it airs. It's true that plenty of fans will understand, but public reaction can go either way. Whether it's good or bad depends on the people watching."

 

"I really don't understand why Namthap did that."

 

"Neither do I. But I want you to think carefully about how you'll deal with the reaction. Once it airs, everyone's attention will turn to you."

 

Every word Thir said drove Karan back towards a painful reality — the fear that he was still selfish enough to destroy the dreams of everyone around him.

 

"I'll talk to Namthap myself."

 

"P'!" Phim's loud voice rang out as the four young men came running towards them.

 

"You're very loud, Phim."

 

Karan quickly wiped the worry from his face and gently scolded him.

 

"Come and have dinner with us! Please? Pretty please?"

 

"No!" Thir cut in before Karan could answer, crushing Phim's hopes.

 

The members looked crestfallen at their manager's merciless refusal.

 

"Why not?"

 

"Exactly, P'! We haven't seen P'Ran for such a long time," Jay and Phim protested, refusing to give up.

 

Namthap and Keen remained silent, but their eyes were just as pleading.

 

"You're idols. What if your fans see you out together?"

 

"That's right. If fans see you or somebody takes pictures, it could cause problems. You know how fast things spread online, especially when you're idols, and everyone pays attention to you. What will you do if something happens?" Karan added.

 

"P'Ran..."

 

"No, Namthap. You're grown up now. You should know what's sensible and what isn't."

 

"P'Thir, as the group's leader, I promise I'll take good care of everyone, and absolutely nothing will happen," Keen said firmly.

 

"That's right. We promise we won't let anything happen. So please let us go," Namthap added.

 

Keen and Namthap's determined voices, combined with Phim and Jay's relentless pleading, finally wore Thir down. In the end, he couldn't stand it and allowed all five of them to go to dinner together.

 

"Please?" "Pleeease?"

 

"Fine! But don't let anyone see you, understand?"

 

The pretty-faced manager raised a warning finger, thoroughly exhausted. Karan could only sigh in resignation. They were just as stubborn as ever.

 

"Thank you!" "Thanks!"

 

"Thank you, P'Thir!" "Thanks, P'!"

 

All four expressed their gratitude enthusiastically.

 

"Have any of you actually asked the person you're inviting?" Thir pointed out, turning towards Karan.

 

"Come with us, P'Ran."

 

"I don't—"

 

"Pleeease, P'~"

 

Karan had intended to refuse, but his eyes met Namthap's pleading gaze, while Phim continued begging beside him. At last he surrendered.

 

"Sigh. All right. I'll go."

 

"Yes!"

 

Phim and Jay celebrated wildly, while Namthap and Keen simply grinned.

 

"Aren't you coming too, P'Thir?" Karan asked.

 

"No. I've got work to get back to. You lot go ahead."

 

"Oh. Then I suppose we'll say goodbye here."

 

"Mm. Go on."

 

Awkward. So unbearably awkward. Phimraphat felt as though he might die.

 

The atmosphere inside the car was so oppressive he could hardly breathe. Nobody said a word. On his left, Jay looked equally miserable.

 

On his right, Keen was entirely expressionless, as though none of it concerned him. Did that idiot never pay attention to anything around him? It was far too quiet.

 

Phim looked left and right in frustration, then had an idea. He switched on the car radio to break the silence, paying no attention whatsoever to what the song meant. A popular song by a famous singer began playing softly.

 

The words gradually reached Karan and Namthap in the front seats. That's right. Loving Namthap had brought such happiness, but in the end their love had reached a dead end.

 

There'd been no way to go on. Their love had been wonderful, yet it had ended all the same. However sweet and happy their past together had been, their relationship had still come to an end.

 

Karan had tried to forget those painful events, but he couldn't. He simply couldn't. Every memory they shared was too precious.

 

Too precious to erase from his heart. Their past was like an old book of immeasurable value. The memories recorded within it served as constant reminders, urging them to move forward, to take the next step for one another.

 

Karan didn't know what Namthap was thinking now. The boy had grown so much that sometimes Karan could no longer guess what went through his mind. When had his little one grown up so completely?

 

The song might have been intended to lighten the mood, but for Karan and Namthap in the front seats, it felt like a small knife repeatedly stabbing an old wound. The pain was almost unbearable. Meeting the person he'd waited for should have been wonderful.

 

So why did Namthap feel as though they were drifting even further apart? Like two parallel lines that could never meet. Close in body, but far apart in heart.

 

Is that what we've become, P'Ran? His eyes trembled. Memories and feelings rushed back so powerfully that he could barely endure them.

 

He wanted to cry, to scream at fate and everything that had forced him and P'Ran to let go of each other's hands. He wanted to tear that wretched contract to pieces. More than anything, he wanted to pull P'Ran into his arms and hold him tightly enough to make up for all their time apart.

 

Phim hummed along without a care in the world. Jay, however, understood the song's meaning, and his expression grew tense. When he looked over and saw his idiot friend happily singing, he wanted to smack him hard on the head.

 

What a bloody fool! Jay wanted to burst into tears himself. The oppressive silence made him feel trapped in a tiny, airless box.

 

He felt confused, uncomfortable and full of pity. Pity for the two people caught in such a painful situation. Although he didn't know every detail of what was happening now, everyone knew the story of the past.

 

There had never been an anniversary when the group could celebrate with completely carefree hearts, because they knew someone had sacrificed something immeasurably precious to help them reach this point. Guilt. Jay, Keen and Phim all felt guilty towards their friend and towards the beloved older brother who was like family to them.

 

They felt guilty for being the reason those two had let go of each other's hands. Namthap constantly told them it wasn't their fault, but how could they enjoy their own happiness while their friend suffered? They couldn't.

 

They just couldn't. Jay clenched his fists tightly. If they'd done more back then, if they'd fought harder, would things have turned out this way?

 

If they'd refused to accept it, would today have been different? He pressed his lips together, his brows drawn tightly together. Suddenly a gentle hand reached out and stroked his clenched fist, soothing it until his fingers relaxed.

 

"You'll hurt yourself," Karan said softly, turning towards him.

 

His pale hand continued stroking Jay's, just as he'd always done in the past. Jay lifted his eyes towards Karan, feeling guilty. Keen and Phim looked over too but said nothing.

 

None of the three could bring themselves to let go of their guilt. The past constantly reminded them who had made their present lives possible.

 

"P'Ran..."

 

"Hmm?"

 

"I..."

 

"We're here. Let's go inside."

 

Karan interrupted Jay because he knew exactly what the boy was going to say. As far as he was concerned, knowing that all four had achieved their dreams was more than enough to make him happy. Even though he'd had to sacrifice something, it had been worth it.

 

Worth it to see every one of them reach the top. Helping his boys achieve their dreams was all he needed. My boys, please don't feel guilty.

 

I made that choice myself, not you. So please keep smiling and be happy. Don't let yourselves be broken any further.

 

"Let's go and eat."

 

Jay nodded obediently like a little boy. The five entered the famous restaurant Namthap had booked. The four idols wore masks and sunglasses to conceal their faces and avoid unwanted attention. A member of staff immediately guided them to their private dining room.

 

The restaurant had a warm, relaxing atmosphere, perfect for a family meal or a gathering of friends. Namthap pulled out a chair for Karan, then took the seat beside him. Keen, Jay and Phim settled into their own seats around the round table, which allowed everyone to share the dishes easily.

 

Karan sat rather stiffly. He wasn't used to such luxurious restaurants. Namthap, who kept a close eye on him, immediately noticed his discomfort.

 

He laughed softly at how adorable Karan was and called the waiter to take their order. They ordered Thai food, just as Karan liked, with particular emphasis on his favourite prawns. Karan hardly had to do anything because the four young men ordered enough dishes to fill the entire table.

 

"P'Ran loves prawns."

 

"That's right! Order lots of prawns, Phim."

 

"Yeah, yeah. I know."

 

"We'll have every prawn dish on the menu, please," Namthap told the waitress without hesitation.

 

He knew exactly what P'Ran liked, so why waste time choosing them one by one? As far as he was concerned, he'd find every prawn in the world for Karan if that was what he wanted. He would never let his sweetheart down.

 

"With that much food, will we be able to finish it?" Karan asked, his eyes widening at the order.

 

Was that boy planning to buy out the restaurant and give the food away afterwards? If they wasted it, Karan would give him a good smack.

 

"You love prawns, P'. And the food here is really good."

 

"Honestly, you..."

 

"For you, I'd buy the entire restaurant if I had to."

 

"That's far too much."

 

"Not at all."

 

"Sigh. Well, that's enough. We won't finish it if you order any more."

 

Karan kept grumbling until all four reluctantly put their menus down. The waitress took their order and left to give them privacy, leaving Karan alone with the idols. This really was the ultimate VIP experience, having dinner with famous idols. Looking at the boys sitting around him, Karan realised this was the kind of thing countless fans could only dream of.

 

"P'Ran, where have you been all this time? Why haven't we ever seen you?" Phim asked.

 

"Don't lie to me, Phim. I know you've all been secretly following me."

 

"You saw us all along?!"

 

Phim's eyes nearly popped out of his head. The other three looked equally flustered. What? Had they been that obvious?

 

"Did you really think you were being particularly subtle?"

 

How could Karan possibly have missed them? Whenever they followed him, all four came together, dressed conspicuously in coats, sunglasses and masks. They made a racket every time they tried to spy on him, especially Phim, Jay and his smiling puppy Namthap.

 

"W-well... we wanted to see you," Namthap mumbled, his pale ears turning red. He rubbed the back of his neck in embarrassment.

 

Hadn't Phim and Jay promised Karan would never spot them? Hadn't they said their disguises were perfect?

 

"Especially you, Namthap. You stood out the most, you know."

 

"Nonsense! Those two idiots were much more obvious than me," he protested, pointing at Jay and Phim.

 

"Hah! You say that, but every time we saw P'Ran, you were the one trying to run straight over to him!"

 

"Exactly. If the three of us hadn't held you back, you'd have blown our cover completely."

 

"Will you three give it a rest?" Keen interrupted, exasperated by their endless bickering and attempts to blame one another.

 

Karan shook his head in resignation. He took back every compliment he'd given them about growing up. Namthap and the two troublemakers sat quietly after being scolded, although they continued shooting childish looks at one another.

 

Soon their food arrived, and the dishes covered almost every available inch of the table. Just looking at it made Karan feel full. Namthap piled food onto Karan's plate until it was heaped with enormous prawns.

 

Karan returned the favour, putting food onto Namthap's plate. His Samoyed puppy beamed because P'Ran had served him. But Karan didn't serve only Namthap.

 

He gave food to everyone — Keen, Jay and Phim. The two troublemakers grinned delightedly. Keen merely smiled faintly, but his eyes shone with happiness.

 

"Eating together like this reminds me of the old days," Keen said nostalgically.

 

"That's true. We were still trainees back then."

 

"Right! P'Ran used to take us out to eat all the time."

 

"Of course I did. You're my little brothers, aren't you?"

 

"I'm not your little brother. I'm your boyfriend," Namthap protested at once, puffing out his cheeks in offence.

 

Karan paid no attention to his complaint and let his thoughts drift back towards their happy past.

 

"We really were so happy back then."

 

At a famous barbecue restaurant, five young men sat waiting hungrily for the meat to cook. The four future idols were particularly ravenous after a gruelling rehearsal. They felt as though they could eat all the meat in the restaurant.

 

Karan, who'd taken charge of the grill, watched the four boys with sympathy. Oh, look at them, gazing so longingly at the food. They must be starving.

 

Seeing how hungrily the four trainees stared at the grill, Karan concentrated on cooking faster. When the meat was ready, he cut it into bite-sized pieces and began distributing it fairly among their plates.

 

"The meat's ready. Pass me your plates."

 

"Me first!"

 

"No, me!"

 

"P', you have to serve me first!"

 

Namthap and the two troublemakers competed to thrust their plates towards Karan. Only Keen sat quietly and waited to be called. Karan sighed softly, picked up Keen's plate and served him first. The other three glared indignantly, especially when they noticed Keen's little victorious smile.

 

"P'! Me first!" Namthap protested loudly.

 

"Sigh. Why are you all making such a fuss? You're all going to get some."

 

Karan took Namthap's plate next and gave his boyfriend some meat. Then he served Jay and Phim as well.

 

"Eat plenty. You've all worked so hard."

 

"Yes, P'!" "Yes!" "Thanks!"

 

"Thank you. But aren't you going to eat, P'?" Keen asked.

 

"Exactly. Why haven't you put any meat on your own plate?" Namthap asked, noticing that Karan hadn't served himself a single piece.

 

"I'm not hungry. You lot eat, and I'll keep cooking for you."

 

"But..."

 

"No buts, Namthap. I'm really not hungry."

 

"All right, you keep grilling, and I'll feed you instead."

 

"I'm not hun—"

 

Grrrrumble~ Before he could finish, Karan's stomach growled loudly in protest. All four boys turned towards him with teasing smiles. His face flushed bright red with embarrassment.

 

"I'm not hungryyyy~"

 

"Ha ha ha!"

 

Phim and Jay gleefully teased him until Karan wanted the ground to swallow him.

 

"Aaaah! Open wide!"

 

His smiling-eyed puppy held a piece of meat wrapped in lettuce up to his mouth, feeding him as though he were a little child. Karan couldn't possibly have been more embarrassed, but in the end he opened his mouth and accepted the bite. Those had been such happy times. When the boys practised hard, he'd come to watch them.

 

When they finished rehearsal exhausted, he took them out for food. Life was tiring, but he was so happy to be with them, to hear their laughter and see their smiles. Karan wanted to preserve the four boys' precious smiles for as long as possible.

 

You deserve happiness more than anyone. Their strength and growth could be heard in their voices and seen in their eyes. It wasn't only Keen; everyone sitting in that room had the same strength in their gaze.

 

Karan looked proudly at all four young men. His heart overflowed with happiness, almost beyond words. Had his boys really grown so strong?

 

"M-mm."

 

Karan nodded slightly. Tears glimmered in his beautiful eyes, filled with overwhelming love and pride.

 

"Then make sure you eat plenty, P'."

 

"You lot too."

 

With that, everyone turned their attention to the food. The room filled with the warmth of a family gathering. The five took turns serving one another, talking and teasing as they ate. Their happy laughter sounded like music so beautiful that nobody could ever tire of hearing it.

 

It didn't take long to finish the meal. Once they were full, Karan excused himself to take a walk and help his digestion. Seeing him leave, Namthap immediately followed.

 

"You can do it, Thap!"

 

"Make sure you win him back!"

 

Phim and Jay whispered encouragement as he left. Namthap headed straight towards a bridge in the restaurant's garden. The cool evening breeze had brought Karan an unexpected sense of peace. Then he was startled when someone wrapped their arms around him from behind.

 

But he recognised Namthap's scent and warmth at once. His body relaxed, and he raised a hand to stroke Namthap's arms gently. That warm embrace, overflowing with love, was still his.

 

In the past, he would have melted into his lover's arms without a thought. But things were different now. Karan still loved Namthap with all his heart, yet he couldn't drag the person most precious to him down.

 

"Namthap, let me go."

 

"No. I'm going to hold you just like this. I'm going to hug you really tightly," Namthap murmured, burying his handsome face against Karan's slender shoulder.

 

"But if someone sees—"

 

"Forget about that for now. I just want to be with you, P'. Please? Please?"

 

Karan felt no differently.

 

"I've missed you so much. Do you know that?"

 

"I know..."

 

Karan answered quietly. Of course he knew how Namthap felt. He understood perfectly how agonising it was, because he was hurting too.

 

"Then can we live together again? I can't stand being without you any longer."

 

"..."

 

"Let's start over, P'."